The inside word out of Washington, D.C. has been that Congressional Republicans are "gun-shy" about most of the races in New York State after the three-way debacle in the 23rd last year.
Greg Ball's abrupt exit from the 19th left the NRCC hesitant about the Hudson Valley, even with Obama winning Democrat John Hall's district with only 52 percent in 2008.
Now the 19th is host to a four candidate race that observers are predicting should whittle down to a two-woman primary by summer.
There's a lot of work for party leaders and candidates to do before it whittles down to anything.
Nan Hayworth
The first casualty won't be Nan Hayworth, though the Mount Kisco moderate is spending money as fast as she is raising it. Also, Hayworth continues not to resonate with all five county chairs -- thought astute political players fully expect her handler Jay Townsend to have substantial proxies in tow by the time a convention is convened. Hayworth has pledged to primary the candidate designated by Republicans, so Sue Kelly's horse in this race will remain until September.
Critics have noted the embittered and sometimes obsessive approach of Hayworth's campaign manager John Hicks. Hicks turned Hayworth's race into a jury on Orange County Republican Chairman Bill DeProspo -- and failed miserably. Hayworth's operatives have also commingled shamelessly with divisive candidates in Putnam and northern Westchester counties. Finally, the manipulative hand of highly-paid political consultant Jay Townsend has been felt and slapped away from the political machinations too many times to list.
Hayworth's loss of frontrunner status has been almost entirely a self-inflicted wound.
David McFadden
Former Tuxedo Mayor David McFadden has pledged not to challenge the Republican's pick and has asked his fellow candidates to join him. McFadden's problem is that his newly changed registration leaves him ineligible to compete in a primary without permission from a majority of the 19th's district leaders or the State GOP chairman. Frankly, McFadden cannot run as a Republican candidate without such a Wilson-Pakula -- so he is sadly a man without a party unless a political miracle happens.
McFadden has impressed gatherings with his speeches. The Orange County native has ably diffused controversies about his tenure as Tuxedo Mayor. He has fearlessly turned negatives about tax liens into a positive commentary on how he kept his company's employees from being laid off. If anything can be said about McFadden, his resilience in this race has not been missed. However, permission to run as a Republican is unlikely for him.
Working in McFadden's favor has been a well-oiled on-the-ground political operation, a surge of social networking tools and a visible presence on both sides of the Hudson River. Working against him is the political tag but it bests the sleepy nature of this race so far.
Kristia Cavere
Newcomer Kristia Cavere is starting to demonstrate that she has an effective ground game. Cavere has impressed tea party and committee members alike with her tough-talking tea party approach. With this Orange County native's campaign projecting close to $300,000 raised, her next FEC filing date (March 31) could turn this into a much different race overnight.
Kristia hasn't formally announced (scheduled tentatively for the second week of April) and she has to hit the ground running to beat down what will still be a well-financed (and well-organized) primary challenge by Hayworth IF (BIG if) Cavere secures all party endorsements in May.
Critics have noted Cavere's absence of a website, campaign Facebook page or any visible campaign structure. She could be one of the brightest candidates in the United States but Cavere's absence from the press -- coupled with not enough retail "shoe leather" campaigning could leave this former Pentagon analyst playing catch-up.
---
To beat John Hall, any of these Republican candidates must be ready to campaign 18 hours a day, seven days a week, every single difficult day until November.
United Republicans?
Neil Di Carlo has an enthusiasm for democracy but it is hoped that the Southeast Republican won't carve away votes from Hayworth and Cavere in a crowded primary. It appears that Di Carlo, though well-intended as a candidate, neither has the funding nor the organization to continue.
The 19th has been measured by Real Clear Politics to be a "toss-up" against John Hall and Republicans would be better off choosing Hayworth or Cavere in the coming days.
The decision on the 19th is likely not being made until early May. News Copy's prediction is that Hayworth will remain in the race as a primary-consuming spoiler if the Bedford Republican does not get the nomination. News Copy has also learned that tea party organizers have grown weary of Hayworth. More important, local leaders will expect much more from Cavere or Hayworth in the coming days and weeks if either woman is to be viewed as the Republican candidate.
David McFadden could still survive as a sleeper if leaders on either side of the county don't start presenting a grass-roots candidate in earnest before April 15th.
Edge to Cavere, if she shows up for the fight.
Recent Comments